Posts

Credible Yardstick Must Be Adopted to Measure Press Freedom

Recommended by the First Press Commission in its 1954 report, the Press Council of India (PCI) was initially established on November 16, 1966, under the Indian Press Council Act, 1965. The constitution of the PCI was envisioned by Smt. Indira Gandhi, who served as the Information and Broadcasting (I&B) Minister from 1964 until January 1966, before becoming Prime Minister and being succeeded by Shri Raj Bahadur. Although the PCI was abolished during the Emergency in 1975 by the Indira Gandhi government, it was re-established in 1979 under the Press Council Act, 1978, by the Morarji Desai government, with Shri L.K. Advani as the I&B Minister. Later, in 1997—during a time when I also served as a member—the decision was taken to celebrate November 16 as National Press Day to commemorate the PCI's establishment. On the occasion of National Press Day, the current government should constitute a Media Commission to study the modern media landscape and propose a genuine regulatory b...

Irretrievable Breakdown of Marriage Must Be Made a Ground for Divorce under the HMA

Law and justice must serve a socially beneficial purpose and remain responsive to the changing needs of society. However, the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, does not adequately address certain realities that spouses encounter in their marital lives. One such pressing issue is the irretrievable breakdown of marriage. Despite its frequent recognition and discussion in judicial pronouncements, it has still not been incorporated as an independent statutory ground for divorce under the Act. Courts in several foreign jurisdictions have also recognised this principle in their matrimonial jurisprudence. In a recent judgment in N. Sridhar Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh, the Supreme Court declined to grant a divorce to a Telugu couple despite their marriage having virtually ceased to exist for nearly two decades. The brief facts of the case are that Dr N. Sridhar Reddy and Geetha Prasanthi were married in 2003 according to Hindu rites and rituals. In 2006, the husband moved to the United Kingdom to...

Police and Lawyers' Ruckus Must Be Resolved Before It Is Too Late

  There is an ongoing confrontation between advocates and the police in Delhi, and similar incidents are witnessed in different parts of the country from time to time. The ultimate sufferer in all such situations is the general public. Go anywhere and ask people about their experience with the police or advocates, and more often than not, you will hear complaints against them. An ordinary person generally avoids visiting a police station or a court unless circumstances leave him with no other option. Hospitals, unfortunately, also fall into a similar category. These are institutions that every citizen may need at some point in life, but nobody wishes to visit them because of the harassment, inconvenience and uncertainty often associated with them. There is a long-standing perception that the police, instead of protecting ordinary citizens, sometimes become a source of harassment for them. An observation attributed to a former judge of the Allahabad High Court compared the polic...

Marriage should be guided by social propriety

 While marriage is fundamentally an individual and private matter, social conventions have long dictated when and how it should occur. Traditionally, individuals are expected to marry upon reaching an acceptable age, often prompted by community expectations placed on their parents. In contrast to this conventional timeline, modern trends show a noticeable shift toward late-life marriages, divorce, and remarriage. This evolution is particularly evident among public figures. Recently, a television journalist married a state Chief Minister; both of them were in their fifties, divorced, and the Chief Minister already had two adult sons working as advocates. Media reports indicated they had been in a relationship for years while waiting for their respective divorces to finalise. Similar instances exist, such as a former long-serving chief minister who facilitated the divorce of his partner so they could marry. Having already raised five children from his previous marriage, this later ...

Saudi Arabia Must Hang Its Head in Shame over the Barbaric Execution of Two Bangladeshis

  How can the so-called civilised nations of the world, particularly those that proclaim themselves champions of human rights, remain silent in the face of the reported execution of two Bangladeshis in Mecca? Where are the voices that rise so readily in defence of human dignity, the rule of law and the right to life when confronted with such a disturbing case? The two Bangladeshis, identified as Nazrul Islam Abdul Basir and Siti Akhtar, were reportedly executed on October 14 over alleged “immoral acts” inside a mosque in Mecca. They were said to have been clicking photographs because it was unthinkable to have indulged in a sexual act in the full glare of thousands of people. Yet Saudi authorities have not publicly disclosed detailed information about the specific acts for which the couple were sentenced to death. When the ultimate punishment is imposed, the public is entitled to ask a fundamental question: what precisely was the offence, what evidence was presented, and by what ...

CJI Surya Kant Deserves Commendation for Refusing to Meet Opposition Leaders

Chief Justice of India Justice Surya Kant deserves to be complimented for refusing to meet a delegation of politicians that included the Leaders of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha. The CJI rightly observed that meeting to discuss matters connected with pending cases would violate the constitutional principle of separation of powers and established norms of judicial propriety. The INDIA Bloc leaders had sought an appointment to submit a memorandum raising concerns over the Chief Election Commissioner of India, alleged arbitrary arrests of students, the closure of metro stations, the cancellation of trains, and other issues. What is particularly objectionable and surprising, however, is the very decision of these political leaders to seek an appointment with the CJI to raise such issues. Did they not understand that the judiciary cannot be approached as a forum for political intervention, nor can political leaders expect the Chief Justice to entertain representa...

CEC can be removed only through certain procedures

  It is nothing short of astonishing that advocates claiming to practise before the Supreme Court should participate in a march demanding the removal of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. One would expect those who claim familiarity with constitutional law to know that the CEC cannot be removed at the government's whim or by street pressure. His removal is governed by a constitutional process comparable to that applicable to a Supreme Court judge. Unlike a minister, who can be removed by the Prime Minister or, in a state, by the Chief Minister, the CEC enjoys constitutionally protected tenure. Neither political expediency nor public agitation can substitute for the procedure prescribed by the Constitution. The CEC can be removed only on the grounds of proved misbehaviour or incapacity . The process requires a motion signed by at least 100 members of the Lok Sabha or 50 members of the Rajya Sabha, followed by its admission by the presiding officer. A three-member inquiry c...